Resealable Packs Which Don't Tear Open Properly?

There seems to be an ever increasing number of products, mainly foodstuffs, which are sold in clip seal bags which have a small cut in either side which are supposed to allow the bag to be simply and cleanly torn open.

Some will not tear at all whilst others do not tear uniformely, so a pair of scissors is required to complete the task.

Even then, sometimes cutting straight from the cut on one to the cut on the other side still does not allow the bag to be opened, and a second cut has to be made lower down near the clip seal.

How hard can it be to manufacture a bag that can be simply opened in this day and age?

image

9 Likes

Agreed!! I find it really frustrating because i have arthritis in my hands and they just arent as strong as they used to be. I have similar issues with jars of pickles which have been vac sealed. Time to get some aids, maybe.

3 Likes

Apparently too hard :wink:

I join with you and @SueW as some closures are ever harder to open, and others are inconsistent (like milk jug seals) where some have more glue than others, and if you don’t have sufficient hand strength too bad.

I complained about difficult milk seals a while back and both Coles and Woolies assured me they met all standards for ‘accessibility’. In retrospect that was like claiming our government(s) work for us rather than themselves as if they were profit making businesses, as often than not.

I am not sure where these are available locally. We bought them while in the USA. They break the vacuum in jars without bending the lids and the tops then come off quite easily. The picture is misleading. One applies the device to gently pop the vacuum and then twists the lid off normally. It is not a pry.

image

4 Likes

I think I may have seen something like this on the Magnamail website. There’s all kinds of gadgetry there, some is good, some mediocre. I’ll have a squiz, because it looks like its very handy.

4 Likes

Like this one?
https://ilcaustralia.org.au/products/462

There are several online retailers who sell specialty products to suit users who have limited strength, arthritis or other physical limitations.

There appears to be a broad range of assistance aids available, many of which may have a broader appeal in the community.

Perhaps also an opportunity for a Choice guide or product reviews with the help of one of the national support organisations?

5 Likes

Well found @mark_m. Interestingly these types of things are commonly available in most kitchenware shops in the US. I had not thought about speciality suppliers.

2 Likes

Robins Kitchen had been a supplier of the D.Line or Brix Jarkeys’ (Trade name I am pretty sure), but as I don’t visit them much possibly not a current item (EDIT Yes they still do). Also can be found in Spotlight at times I believe. House.com.au (same stores as Robins Kitchen under a different name) also stock/supply it both online and in their stores.

https://www.robinskitchen.com.au/kitchen/kitchenware/jar-~-can-openers

https://www.house.com.au/kitchen/kitchenware/jar-~-can-openers

For the packets that you have to tear at the little weakened notch on the sides see the following as these may be possible time and effort savers.

This one requires the use of a board or something similar underneath to help the cutting and saving bench/table damage:
https://www.officeworks.com.au/shop/officeworks/p/slice-safety-cutter-green-xpsl00100

Or on the following pages the 2 Klever items which don’t require a board and they also have replaceable heads when the blades get blunt:

https://www.rsea.com.au/hardware/tools/diplomat-blades-klever-x-change-safety-knife-klever-x-change

https://www.rsea.com.au/hardware/tools/diplomat-blades-klever-knife-double-wall-head-klever-excel-dx

The second Klever Excel DX one is a much cheaper option than the first Klever one.

The next one is from the same manufacturer but does not have replaceable blades:
https://www.rsea.com.au/hardware/tools/diplomat-blades-klever-kutter-safety-knife-klever-kutter

You might even be able to get a free sample (I don’t know if you will but they do offer the free sample as part of their promo video) by ringing Diplomat Blades about their “Klever Innovations” on (03) 9562 0777. YMMV

3 Likes

You are welcome. I also recollect seeing a variety of jar and bottle opening devices in a small physical store that specialised in aids for the elderly etc.

So there may be more options?

The more options the better given the increased number of us post 60, 70 etc who choose to remain independent.

2 Likes

And this

2 Likes

These bag’s drive me crazy! foodland put their lamb chop’s in them, and I struggle everytime to open them, I complained to the supermarket, and their reply was that is was more hygenic, I hate them!

1 Like

Agree that most of the ones we use don’t work properly
while some may seal okay, the same bags don’t ‘tear’ along the nominated area or the bags tear okay but the seal is not 100% effective.

The only one which I can recall that did work was Tassal Australian smoked Salmon cooking pieces. The bag ihas perforations to allow tearing exactly where it should and the seal water tight (which is needed when replacing partly used product back in the fridge for future use.

Maybe other product manufactures which also use similar bags could see what Tassal’s are doing to see if they can also get it right.

1 Like

I’ve given up on resealable as a reason to purchase one product over another, except for the rare package with a zip seal built in. And then some of these are not always reliable or easy to use.

I’d rather save the 2c on the design and waste in extra packaging to see a saving in the cost of the product.

We simply put the opened and unused portion inside a clean zip seal fridge/freezer bag. We know they work and can be washed for reuse.

4 Likes

I have used a jar key for many years now. Most good kitchen stores should stock them.

3 Likes

A comment on a slightly different subject, but as there have been several replies regarding disability issues, I have posted it here.

I bought a 30 pack of Energiser AA alkaline batteries this week and I needed to use 6 of them tonight.

The tamper-proof welded plastic packaging was not provided with any means of being opened other than cut, unlike some other packs which have a paper backing, and even perforations to assist opening.

I used a razor sharp small utility knife but I still had great difficulty in managing to cut the plastic right around the perimeter.

I would suspect that it would be nigh-on impossible for a frail person, someone with arthritis, or anyone without a sharp instrument to achieve, and everyone risks the possibility of a nasty cut.

The pack of 24 Energiser AAA alkaline batteries I bought at the same store a few days earlier had a thin cardboard back which I quickly and easily removed.

What is Energiser thinking? That people are going to open and steal the AA batteries but not the much smaller, lighter and more expensive AAA batteries?

Hello.

image

1 Like

Exactly. Ziplock baggies are a stronger variety than most (eg freezer bags) and they work well. I bought one pack a few years ago and am only now getting down to the last few because the others have been washed and reused to heck and gone. I also have a variety of sealable plastic containers (and even some glass ones with plastic sealing lids) for fridge storage, but I find the ziplocks to be most space efficient.

1 Like

Has anyone tried to open a BandAid lately in a hurry? What a nightmare, why do they do this, I have to use one every day a the moment, and I have to resort to scissors.

3 Likes

These are my bottle opening devices. The white ones are battery operated and brilliant.

2 Likes

I totally agree. It is ridiculous to have these packets as you can never open them unless you use scissors. :grimacing:

2 Likes

I thoroughly agree. We have two small dogs and the treats packets are notorious for not opening along the dotted line. As earlier stated, even scissors along the line is not always successful first time. While on the topic, we have grand children and recently their muesli bars and other packets are impossible for an adult to open let alone a child at school. Even juices and milk now require a gadget to unscrew the lids as it is getting harder to break the seal. Maybe companies need a couple of us oldies to point out the deficiencies of “easy open” and also come up with a solution; like we had to do in the olden days (as my grandchildren say).

2 Likes

Another annoyance are bottles with an attached lid which breaks off.

My GP told me to take 3 Blackmores Vitamin D3 capsules daily around 7 years ago and I buy the 200 capsule bottles.

Only once did the attached lid not break off before the bottle was empty.

My GP recently told me to now only take 1 cqpsule daily so I will undoubtedly never see a bottle again where the lid does not break off.