CHOICE membership

Quiz: Can You Guess The Healthiest Product?

Hey everyone,

Just re-sharing a quiz that we put out last week! This is a fun quiz about Health Stars.

Health Stars are only displayed on packaged products (so the products in the quiz do not reflect a balanced diet). This usually lets us compare like for like, and identify:
a) how healthy a product is
b) how a product compares against others in its category (e.g. yoghurts are one category)

The trouble is, Health Stars are not displayed on every product, making it extremely different to compare products within categories. Do you think this is the case? Would you like to see Health Stars on more products? Take our quiz below:

7 Likes

I didn’t do very well in that quiz, as it was mostly about products I’ve never heard of and would never buy, and I wasn’t able to read the “nutrition facts” labels!

6 Likes

A lot of these aren’t products I buy either. With that being said, it’s still important for us to be able to assess the healthiness of them using a quick and easy front of pack labelling system.

The nutrition information panel is an awesome tool (which I love) but for those of us who don’t understand it, can’t read it, or are time poor, Health Stars are a great alternative (when they’re on packets!).

Thanks for taking our quiz!!!

7 Likes

Only on the Apricot Bars did I get it wrong as I guess 1.5 stars and the correct one was 2.5 stars. I’d still say 1.5 was closer :smile:

I support a useful Health Star rating system but some items such as the old 4.5 stars for Milo because it had to have added skim milk skews the usefulness.

4 Likes

You’ll be happy to know that the ‘as prepared’ rule that you’re referring to in the comment above has been changed! That’s great news for us - Milo can no longer game the system with the skim milk trick.

7 Likes

Yes indeed it makes me very happy!!

4 Likes

Also did poorly…never bought any of the products and only seen most on the shelves at the local supermarket. Not the sort of foods we buy (with exception of yoghurts which we buy at a local fruit and vegetable grocer (only milk, culture and pectin).

Looking at a package by itself it is difficult to acertain what is the healthiest. If the nutritional panel was included, it would have made the quiz potentially easier.

We don’t buy from looking at the overall packaging alone…use ingredients list and nutritional panel as well.

7 Likes

Totally agree.
Just by a lucky guess I got two right.
Hopeless without more info from box etc …

7 Likes

It would seem that we have a healthy audience, because I didn’t know one of those products either.

Guessing got me successfully through to lasgne where, apart from the yoghurt, it all went pear shaped.

The problem is that we are relying on the food manufaturers to be ethical in providing us with information on the contents and health star ratings. Problem is that too often ethics go out the window when the question of profits walk in the door. There is no ‘big stick’ that would make food manufacturers think twice about being rather exigious with the truth.

7 Likes

Thanks @LindaPrzhedetsky.
I was feeling great till I finished the quiz and realised just how much other junk food is out there. Yes the test show just how Hard it can be to know with some products if they are healthy and also good value.

I think I guessed two right. No science, just blind faith. It did not help.

P.s. I’m all for products which would reasonably be considered discretionary being banned from being able to display health stars. Give them a no rating, not healthy symbol, or as discussed some where on previous Choice discussions a reverse score. IE perhaps a score of one says eat very little infrequently, a score of 5 no more than one handful a day. Hand size calibration optional.

How do you sell a reverse scoring system for such foods.:thinking:

Ask Gruen if they can provide the answer? Add agencies seem to be able to sell anything.

7 Likes

I had no idea. just goes to show how much I actually rely on the star ratings and the product information panels.

6 Likes

@LindaPrzhedetsky, @BrendanMays, Choice should consider developing a travelling kiosk style game ‘booth’ with this and similar quizzes and consumer focused entertainment ala Checkout or Shonkys style. Since it would have to be funded a pilot could also sell Choice subscriptions to see how it goes.

It could be offputting to shops and manufacturers so might be best used at local festivals or in public areas of shopping centres rather than in-shops. Schools - many politics but is there a Choice nutrition lesson plan for those schools so interested? Idealistically imagine purpose built quiz machines in the yoghurt isle, etc!

Adding the quizzes to the Choice home page as you have been doing is a good one but has comparatively limited visibility.

6 Likes

Most of these products would not be part of my diet anyway. Muesli bars are very dense in kilojoules. I would want to see the nutrition panel rather than the stars, which are being expertly manipulated by the manufacturers and are practically useless as an accurate indicator of the “goodness” of a product. Most people still think five stars means the product is good for you. And the plain popcorn… how many people do you think would eat it plain? They would probably roll it in sugar or icing etc to give it a flavour.

4 Likes

The question is why should you have to?

1 Like