Paper shopping bags: environmentally friendly?

Plastic shopping bags are no longer provided at shops, many of us have got used to ‘bring our own bags’ but sometimes we forget or are doing an unexpected trip, we then have the option to buy a paper shopping bag at the checkout.

Paper usage is growing at high levels. It’s considered a better alternative to Plastic bags and ideal for purchases where we don’t have our own carry bags.

In Australia 1 billion paper bags are consumed each year. The increasing demand for paper has led to a rapid development of the paper industry. Globally, about 4 billion trees per year are cut down for paper production. What impact does that industry have on the environment?

Pros:

Paper bags are ‘Biodegradable’, they degrade naturally returning nutrients to the soil, produce fertilisers, can be buried in the soil without contaminating it, don’t leave any toxic waste. (Although in landfills they break down into methane, a greenhouse gas.)

Paper is a strong material, can support weight, can be reused a few times.

It’s made from a renewable resource: can be recycled, grocery paper bags are often made from recycled paper collected and processed at a recycling paper factory.

Cons:

Deforestation:
The big environmental problem we are facing these days.
Trees are necessary to provide cellulose fibres for pulp, paper and packaging production, our consumption requires billions of trees to be cut down increasing the rate of deforestation globally.
Worldwide deforestation is estimated to be responsible for about 12% of greenhouse gas emissions.
(There are some 'Managed Forests’: planting new seedlings where trees have been harvested. How long it takes for a tree to grow for paper making depends on many factors, generally Pine trees can take 30-40 years, Eucalyptus under 10 years.)

Water consumption

Huge water consumption and discharge of toxic wastewater:
It takes between 2 and 13 litres of water to make one A4 sheet of paper, depending on the mill.
A huge amount of toxic wastewater is discharged from each step of the paper making process, and goes through rigorous treatment stages before being discharged into waterways.

Energy consumption

The whole process of paper making consumes large amount of energy, ranking 4th as the largest industrial energy user worldwide.

Polluting gases

Nitrogen dioxide, Sulfur dioxide, Carbon dioxide are harmful gases released into the atmosphere during the paper making process.

Limited Recycling

Cannot be recycled more than 5-7 times because the fibres no longer stick to each other.

Consumers awareness
As consumers we can be more aware of the impact of using paper and take steps to reduce paper waste:
Reduce
Reuse
Recycle
Buy recycled paper products,
reduce amount of paper copies, note paper and so on..
go digital to store documents..
use digital version of books..

4 Likes

There is also some discussion about using paper bags and their environmental impact in the ‘Paying for shopping bags’ topic, particularly towards the bottom entries of the topic.

Taking natural fabric bags such as made from cotton, or similar fabrics, is a good alternative choice to either plastics or paper bags. Even production of fabric can use lots of water, though typically the natural fabric bag is reusable many many times and is compostable at end of life.

5 Likes

Yes.
About delivered grocery orders, I believe that now the packaging of choice by the stores are paper shopping bags, compounding the problem of paper usage.

2 Likes

I put a sample from a supermarket paper bag in water for about an hour and it did not deteriorate some plastic perhaps.

1 Like

My Mum, ( and everyone else’s mum) used to take her netted bags to the shops. The butcher used to wrap purchases in old newspapers (re cycle 60’s style) as did the fruit and veg shops That was back in the 60’,70’s then in the 80’s came the rise of the supermarkets and the fall of local grocers. Supermarkets needed long life packaging (plastics) for their cold stores storage( weeks and weeks) and handling protection when shipping from distribution centres to local stores. So I guess that’s progress….:roll_eyes:

3 Likes

It could be treated Kraft paper, a special coating can be applied to make the paper resistant to water/moisture.

1 Like

Brown paper bags are unbleached (hence the brown colour) kraft paper. The name ‘kraft’ comes from the name of the pulping process and brown paper is usually made from softwoods because their cellulose fibres are longer compared to those from most hardwoods and hence make a stronger paper.

If the sheet doesn’t disintegrate when soaked in water it may have been coated with something or some water proofing has been incorporated in the sheet. Cardboard milk cartons are actually laminated with a sort of normal outer layer (although this seems to be coated as well) with an inner layer which used to be called ‘Tetrapak’ which was a paper that was made with a urea-formaldehyde resin incorporated in it to give it a high degree of moisture resistance. It could be recycled with some difficulty (low ph and elevated temperature). The APPM paper mills in Burnie (Tas) made this years ago.

2 Likes

Still better than releasing micro- and nanoplastics, contaminating our oceans, air, soils, and human body.