Here’s parts three and four of our series into ethical super:
5 Likes
Really good reads and interesting how some funds sidestep the questions of why they invest in ways that are/appear “unethical”.
4 Likes
I initially started my super with Christian Super, but later down the line I decided to review it and moved to Australian Ethical for that exact reason. Their ethics policy really didn’t line up with what I considered ‘ethical’
I’m currently satisfied with Australian Ethical as they’re good at communicating changes when companies they’re invested in are called into question. Whilst I loathe the big banks I also understand the idea that some investments may need to be in that industry.
At the end of the day I’m able to make these decisions because both of those funds have detailed ethics policies easily available. For me this is the most important aspect of ethical investment
3 Likes
@XavierOHalloran from Super Consumers will be speaking at this special event discussing how your super can impact on ethical issues such as environmental destruction and what you can do to align your retirement nest egg to your values for those interested.
5 Likes
Doing a periodic review of our super funds I noticed the Perpetual Ethical SRI Fund. Its 10 year return is respectable, less so in recent times. But I digress and am not getting into industry vs retail, noting our retail mix has done quite well in spite of ‘high fees’.
The fund is stated to: … invest in quality companies that have satisfied our range of ethical and socially responsible investment criteria.Perpetual is also a signatory to the United Nations-supported Principles for Responsible Investing (PRI), and in relation to this fund, use research from external specialists to analyse socially responsible practices of companies listed on the Australian and overseas exchanges.
The fund’s top 10 investments include some notable companies, especially 2 of our big 4 banks and Nick Scali. Ethical?
It appears ethical may be a technical investment term in context, perhaps related to how an ‘ethical’ company operates on its supply side, or ticks some environmental boxes, while loosely or unrelated to how it interacts with its customers.
5 Likes
There can often be confusion between ‘Ethical Investments’ and ‘Lack of undeniably unethical investments.’ Some investors and consumers just want their stock out of businesses like weapons and fossil fuels. Where others would consider ethical to actually mean an investment in businesses actively seeking to be ethical and progressive.
As it stands super fund members are still in the dark, with no obligation for funds to disclose which of these they are or what they invest in, unlike what is typical for investor funds like that one.
2 Likes
This is an interesting development…
Usually ASIC doesn’t undertake investigations for the sake of it, but usually in response to information provided to them or they have identified through other investigations. It might be a ‘watch this space’ to see if the claims being made by (some) ethical super funds are correct or misleading (greenwashing).
4 Likes
When I first started a super fund I followed my parents and set it up with Christian Super. Later on when I went back to check it, I decided to look into which funds most aligned to my ethics. Much to my surprise, Christian Super had little to no environmental investment policies. I didn’t think investing in multi-national corporations involved in global environmental destruction was very Christian personally. To their credit, they have since significantly improved their exclusion policy.
I am currently with Australian Ethical
2 Likes
Ethical investing apparently has multiple criteria as well as multiple meanings to multiple funds and investors.
2 Likes
Can anyone advise on how to select a an ethical super fund? I’m struggling to be certain and I want to ensure my money is investing in saving this planet not further destroying it
1 Like
I merged your post into this older one regarding ethical funds. If you peruse prior posts, especially those by @AndyKollmorgen and @BrendanMays, there are links to admittedly dated Choice articles.
A related dashboard being developed by Choice and Superconsumers has been delayed, apparently to 2027 now.
I hope this reply has been helpful.
3 Likes
I’ve been with Australian Ethical for a number of years and I’ve always been very happy with them.
Returns and fees are declared in easy to understand language with a number of investment options available. Their ethical charter is stricter than others I’ve looked at (I moved from Christian Super prior to Australian Ethical absorbing it after realising Christian Super didn’t exclude fossil fuel investment). Sometimes with large decisions they actually email members explaining why they chose to divest or not, which I really appreciate.
I’m not a financial advisor so wont comment on the performance side of things etc. Best to seek advise from one if you’re unsure. I’ll also acknowledge that there was recently a personal story in the media of someone who had a poor insurance experience with Australian Ethical, although of course this is provided by a third party.
4 Likes
I’ll second that. I’ve been with AE for many years. The only time I was a little perturbed was a very long while ago when they said they were investing in Blackmore’s, some of whose products I didn’t think were totally ethical. Other than that, I’ve been very happy with them.
4 Likes
